Cartilage is a firm, rubbery, and very smooth surface. There is cartilage on the ends of the bones of your knee. That allows your knee to glide and move easily without pain. Injuries to the knee can cause damage to the cartilage which could lead to a cartilage defect or hole in the cartilage.
Have you been told that you are “missing cartilage” in your knee? The inner side of the knee or the medial femoral condyle is the most common area for a cartilage defect. It is also the easiest area to repair a cartilage defect. This post will cover the various techniques available to repair cartilage defects of the knee.
Types of Cartilage:
In the human knee there are two forms of cartilage. We have the two cushions, each of which we call a meniscus. We also have cartilage on the end of the thigh bone or femur, and cartilage that covers the top of the shin bone or tibia. This cartilage is known as articular cartilage. Damage to the articular cartilage will be the focus of this post. If you have been told that you are “missing cartilage in your knee” your physician is likely referring to the articular cartilage on ends of the bone, and not the meniscus.
Cartilage “Tears” vs Cartilage “Defects” :
If you have been diagnosed with a “cartilage tear” your physician was probably referring to a meniscus tear. If your physician says you have a hole or defect in your cartilage, they are likely referring to the “articular” cartilage layer. The articular cartilage is typically 1/8-1/4″ thick in an adult knee. It is a firm, exceptionally smooth surface and enables your joints to glide and move without friction, grinding, catching or discomfort. The picture above shows normal appearing cartilage on the end of the femur and the top of the tibia when viewed during an arthroscopic procedure.
Meniscus tears and articular cartilage injuries or defects (holes) are completely different injuries — apples and oranges — and require different treatment plans or procedures to address them.
Injuries to articular cartilage can occur in many ways. Many injuries occur in teenagers in track and field, soccer or football. Sports injuries can cause a piece of cartilage to rip off the end of the bone (see the image below). Cartilage injuries are uncommon, but will produce pain, swelling, locking, and a feeling that something is loose within the knee.
By far the most common cause of injury is the result of blunt trauma such as a fall from a height, a fall directly onto the front of the knee or a car accident where the knee hits the dashboard.
In certain situations, osteoarthritis will cause defects or holes in the cartilage too. Osteoarthritis, by definition means that the cartilage on the ends of the bone is becoming thin due to degeneration. If you lose a little cartilage, that is mild arthritis. If you loose all the cartilage, you have severe arthritis. This post deals with defects or holes in the cartilage and not necessarily arthritic defects where all the cartilage in the knee is thin or lost.
Here are two pictures obtained during an arthroscopy where a fiber-optic camera is placed in the knee. In the
upper picture you can see the cartilage literally peeling off of the bone beneath it. This is an acute or fresh defect. The picture below shows that scar tissue has tried (ineffectively) to fill a defect that has been present for months.
Cartilage injuries can be severe, because cartilage loss can lead to knee osteoarthritis. Cartilage defects, if large enough, are best treated as soon as they are recognized. To see if a cartilage defect is present, an MRI is usually necessary. An MRI is very useful to demonstrate the location, size and repairability of a cartilage defect.
Once the diagnosis is made,your surgeon can discuss the various techniques available to “repair” the defect in the cartilage. We have many good procedures to help restore knee cartilage, but none of them are perfect and some are more invasive than others. The most common cartilage repair procedures available are:
Cartilage Defects Treatment – Micro-Fracture
A Micro-fracture or “Marrow Stimulating Technique” is an arthroscopic technique and involves making many small holes in the cartilage hole or defect. After the holes are made bone marrow cells, stem cells and blood will come out of the holes and coat the cartilage defect. Theoretically those new cells in the knee will grow within the hole in the cartilage and result in healing. Healing occurs with a repair cartilage called fibrocartilage. Fibrocartilage is not the same as the original hyaline articular cartilage. It has different properties and might not stand the test of time.
Cartilage Defects Treatment – Carticel
Genzyme developed a procedure known as Carticel. This involves two procedures. The first is an arthroscopic assesment of your defect and if we believe you are a good candidate for a Carticel procedure, we will take a small biopsy of normal cartilage. Genzyme will amplify, or grow the cartilage cells and send them back to us. During a second stage procedure those cells are implanted under a patch we sew over the hole in the cartilage.
A MACI procedure is similar to an ACI or carticel procedure. There is an important difference. After the company grows your cartilage cells the cells will be implanted into a membrane which we glue into the cartilage defect. This shortens the procedure time and should result in a more uniform cartilage repair. Research studies show that this procedure generally produces a more “hyaline like” cartilage, or a more normal type of cartilage.
DeNovo Cartilage Grafting
The DeNovo technique has gained a lot of attention recently. The initial results being published are promising, but not a guarantee of success. The DeNovo technique involves implanting immature cartilage cells into a defect or hole in the cartilage and covering it with a biological glue. This is an open procedure. The DeNovo technique is discussed in more detail here in a separate post.
Osteochondral Grafting or Cartilage Transplant (OATS):
Cartilage Grafting or Cartilage Transplant procedures is sometimes referred to as a moscaicplasty. I find this to be one of the more satisfying and successful procedures for fixing large cartilage defects in the knee. A cartilage transplant or grafting involves taking cartilage from a cadaver and transferring it to fill the cartilage defect in your knee. One of the advantages of a cartilage transplant is that we are placing living, firm articular cartilage into the defect. Below are images from two different patients. In both instances you see the cartilage defect in the image on the left, and then the end-result after the defects were filled with a cartilage transplant to the right.
Recovery from cartilage surgery
After most of these procedures you will need to be on crutches for a number of weeks. The amount of time on crutches will vary depending on this size of your cartilage defect, the location of the defect and the procedure you had. Physical therapy and range of motion activities are typically started soon after surgery. Cartilage nutrition is improved by moving the knee.
Depending on the procedure you had it might take 8-12 months for a complete recovery. Cartilage transplants or allografts tend to heal faster. Many athletes and weekend warriors will be able to return to sports after a successful cartilage repair.
Traumatic cartilage defects are not very common injuries, but they can have significant consequences if they are untreated. Large defects can lead to osteoarthritis. Technology is improving in this area as our understanding of cartilage improves. Many cartilage defects are now amenable to one of the various techniques that we reviewed in this post.
Dr. Howard Luks, MD – Hawthorne, NY
Fax: (914) 789-2743
Dr. Howard Luks, MD – Fishkill, NY
Fax: (914) 789-2743