• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Howard J. Luks, MD, Orthopedic Surgeon

Howard J. Luks, MD

Orthopedic Surgeon Sports Medicine Specialist

  • Articles
  • Notes
  • Podcast
  • Book
  • Education
    • Shoulder Injuries
    • Knee Injuries
    • Elbow Injuries
  • About
Blog / Articles / Knee

Is Surgery For a Degenerative Knee Successful? Getting the Story Right.

Howard J. Luks, MD Updated September 23, 2021

Osteoarthritis of the knee affects millions of you.  The pain from knee arthritis can be mild or quite severe and crippling.  Arthroscopic knee surgery is often discussed  as a treatment option when you have arthritis AND a meniscus tear in combination.  But this is a very controversial area, and it’s important that you understand what your realistic options are.  There was a recent article in the NY Times which unfortunately provided more misleading information.   I think that the article (referenced below) did not present the subject matter well since there are a subset of arthritic patients who do very well after arthroscopic surgery.

Any active readers of my blog know that I strongly believe we are an over-diagnosed and over-treated society.  But, articles such as the one quoted below can be very misleading and require clarification. First the video …

Surgery for Arthritis and Meniscus Tears. Who Might Benefit.

From the NY Times piece…

…People in their 50s and older often get arthroscopic surgery for knee pain, but a new review of studies suggests that it has serious risks and no lasting benefits.

Source: Surgery for Knee Pain May Not Provide Benefits – The New York Times

Now .. let’s be clear.  Arthroscopic surgery for arthritic symptoms… that dull throbbing awful ache is generally not successful.. and very arthritic knee are cranky and do not appreciate being operated on unless they are being replaced.

The patient who MIGHT benefit from arthroscopic surgery is the arthritic patient who also has a meniscus tear AND also has mechanical symptoms –

  • popping
  • locking
  • sharp pains with turning
  • buckling and giving way.

As you can see by the comments at the end of the NY Times article there are many people who are very happy that they chose to have surgery.  They remain active years after the surgery.  The key here is proper patient selection, and managing expectations.

Categories: Knee, Knee Arthritis, Surgery

Disclaimer:  this information is for your education and should not be considered medical advice regarding diagnosis or treatment recommendations. Some links on this page may be affiliate links. Read the full disclaimer.
Longevity... Simplified: Living A Longer, Healthier Life Shouldn’t Be Complicated

My new book is available now.

“The seven simple steps to make ‘longevity simplified’, will help to improve your metabolic health right now.” – Dr. Neil Meigh

Learn More
Read Reviews

Related Articles

same day knee replacement surgery
Ambulatory – Same Day Knee Replacement?
Bowed legs and medial knee pain
High Tibial Osteotomy For Knee Arthritis Pain In Active People
Benefits of exercise
Walk, Exercise, Running, and Living with Knee Arthritis
should I have surgery
Elective Surgery Optimization: A Paradigm Shift
remain active with knee osteoarthritis
10 Recommendations To Thrive With Osteoarthritis of the Knee
Thigh strength decreases the risk of developing knee arthritis
Thigh Strength and The Risk of Developing Knee Arthritis
Howard J. Luks, MD

Howard J. Luks, MD is an orthopedic surgeon & sports medicine specialist. An expert in shoulder, knee, and other sports injuries, he is widely known as one of the country’s best orthopedic surgeons.

Book Appointment · About · Contact

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube

Like what you’re reading?

Get the latest posts in your inbox

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Mark A. Deitch, MD says

    June 23, 2015 at 8:07 pm

    Dr Luks – Do you have data to support your assertions? I agree that the NY Times article is misleading, but in order to counteract this, we need quality data. -Mark Deitch, MD, MBA

Primary Sidebar

Howard J. Luks, MD is an orthopedic surgeon & sports medicine specialist. An expert in shoulder, knee, and other sports injuries, he is widely known as one of the country’s best orthopedic surgeons.

Book Appointment · About · Contact

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube

Like what you’re reading?

Get the latest posts in your inbox

Longevity... Simplified: Living A Longer, Healthier Life Shouldn’t Be Complicated

My new book is available now.

Learn More
Read Reviews

Reader Favorites

  • Batters shoulder posterior labral tear
    Batter’s Shoulder : Posterior Labral Tears
  • LEg exercises improve longevity
    Runners require strength too: What to do and when to do it
  • calcific tendonitis and severe shoulder pain
    Why Does My Shoulder Hurt So Much?
  • lactate polarized training
    Lactate, the lactate shuttle, and lactate threshold workouts in polarized training
  • Zone 2 heart rate training
    Zone 2 Heart Rate Training For Longevity and Performance
  • knee swelling
    Pain In The Front Of The Knee: 6 Common Causes
  • Polarized training for runners
    Polarized training for everyday runners: Part 1
  • Exercise is more important than ever
    Does Exercise Cause Osteoarthritis?

Howard J Luks, MD

Orthopedic Surgery & Sports Medicine
128 Ashford Avenue
Dobbs Ferry, NY 10522

Phone: (914)-559-1900
Book Appointment

Pages

  • About
  • Upcoming Books
  • Testimonials
  • In The News
  • Media Photos
  • Contact

Topics

  • Shoulder
  • Knee
  • Elbow
  • Metabolic Health
  • Osteoarthritis
  • Training

More

  • COVID
  • Ankle
  • Hip
  • PRP
  • Running
  • Sports Medicine
  • Articles
  • Notes
  • Podcast
  • Book
  • Education
  • About

© 2023 · Howard J Luks, MD · Disclaimer & Terms · Privacy Policy
The information on this site is not intended or implied to be medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
This site should be used for informational purposes only.