…and we should NOT think like mechanics.

Orthopedists and Twitter

Thanks to an orthopedic colleague, Dr. Katherine Burns, the Orthopedic community and any other interested parties on twitter were given a chance to observe for the first a well done live tweeting of an orthopedic meeting — focusing predominantly on the shoulder. Now,  those of you have been around twitter for a long time,  and certainly those of you who attended many healthcare meetings, and certainly healthcare marketing meetings clearly know that live tweeting of events is nothing new, however,  from an orthopedic perspective — this was a big leap forward.

We are not mechanics… We treat patients, not MRI findings

The one upsetting issue is a theme that I see repeated over and over in the realm of orthopedic surgery,  both in resident education, in what many people are told in offices around the world,  as well as the focus of much of the literature that I read in the realm of shoulder surgery.   That is the issue of *Mechanical Thinking*. Something is broken or torn so I must fix it!

A not insignificant focus withing the orthopedic literature —  and certainly most of this meeting which was live tweeted focused on how to fix something, what techniques could be utilized to fix something, and what the overall results were from utilizing those techniques. The didactic sessions were followed by a laboratory session where the surgeon attendees were actually able to perform the surgery on cadavers in order to hone their skills.  That’s all well and good.  HOWEVER, this assumes that surgery was *necessary* or advisable in the first place. There was very little discussion centered about who needs surgery, when they need surgery, or why they need surgery.

A Patient Centric Approach

I received many questions through my website and certainly in my office in the form of second opinions where people put forth the issue that surgery was being recommended to repair a rotator cuff tear – – – yet they had relatively little if any discomfort.  Many people offered that their pain was having little if any effect on their quality of life … and important Shared Decision Making principle.  These were typically situations where they most likely had shoulder pain for a short period of time and were referred for an MRI (perhaps a little early), a rotator cuff tear was identified and purely mechanical thinking led to the recommendation for surgery.  Since the recommendation, most of the patients who presented had already realized significant improvement in their pain and they were wondering whether surgery was indicated.

Orthopedic surgeons have been taught in the past that most tears *need* to be fixed. Again, mechanical thinking – – – if something is broken, we must fix it. We now know that this  is probably not true. Why don’t I use the word probably? I use the word probably simply because we don’t have enough evidence to say with absolute certainty what tears need to be fixed and which tears do not need to be fixed. Very few surgeons would argue that acute or posttraumatic tears of the rotator cuff truly deserve to be fixed. However, many tears, or in fact most tears of the rotator cuff are attritional in nature — this is where the tissue simply wore out.  The analogy that I frequently use is — your favorite pair of blue jeans you’ve been wearing for years. You look down one day or you feel a breeze around your knee and you look down and there is a hole in the front of your bluejeans.  Did you rip it purposefully,  did you lean on it or kneel on it or inflict some form of trauma to your pants :-) ? No, the tissue,  or in this case the fabric simply wore out.    So if that tissue is wearing out and we choose to repair it what’s the likelihood that the tissue has the ability to heal?  If it is *successfully* repaired – – – because the tissue is degenerative, what’s to prevent it from simply tearing again?  Once again, we simply do not have good answers to those questions.

Do I *need* surgery?

The same issue came up with  labral tears. There was a lot of discussion about techniques to be utilized to fix labral tears, what techniques should be utilized in various age groups, etc.  The number one number question in my mind,  however,  was not well addressed.  That question of course is — “Do labral tears need to be fixed?”   In many situations the answer is clearly yes. If your shoulder is unstable or dislocating then you need to have your labor repaired to minimize the risk of re-dislocation. If you are an overhead athlete and you sustain a labral tear, do you need to have that repaired?  Occasionally the answer is yes. Unfortunately, some recent literature has shown that the vast majority of high-performance overhead athletes are not able to return to their prior level of function following a labral repair. Are surgeons informing these overhead athletes about these facts?  There are many surgical success stories where we are clearly able to return a high-performance athletes back to their usual function.  But it does not appear that labral surgery in this unique patient population is often successful … in weekend warriors and many high school or college players, a repair appears to be successful.  But the margin for success is not high.

So, by and large this was a good week for the world of Orthopedics and Social Media. There are many more orthopedic surgeons on Twitter and other social media properties. This will ultimately prove to be a *good thing* for people searching for quality orthopedic information.

Eminence  vs Evidence Based Medicine and Surgical Decision Making

On the flip side .. due to the persistence of Eminence Based Medicine in the community and the issue of purely mechanical thinking  — I simply suggest that you temper your decision to proceed with a recommended surgery until you obtain a very clear understanding and an adequate  discussion about the evidence that exists as to why the suggestion for shoulder surgery is  being made — prior to you considering   surgery.  Have a clear understanding of what shared decision-making principles are. Perhaps even utilize the multitude of shared decision-making tools which are available to you on the Internet. If your surgeon is either not willing or capable of discussing the evidence or going through a shared decision making process with you — consider a second opinion—  or moving on.

 

Disclaimer:  this information is for your education and should not be considered medical advice regarding diagnosis or treatment recommendations. Some links on this page may be affiliate links. Read the full disclaimer.

Related Posts

About the author:

Howard J. Luks, MD

Howard J. Luks, MD

A Board Certified Orthopedic Surgeon in Hawthorne, NY. Dr. Howard Luks specializes in the treatment of the shoulder, knee, elbow, and ankle. He has a very "social" patient centric approach and believes that the more you understand about your issue, the more informed your decisions will be. Ultimately your treatments and his recommendations will be based on proper communications, proper understanding, and shared decision-making principles – all geared to improve your quality of life.

28 comments on “Decision Making for Labral Tears and Rotator Cuff Tears [video]

  • Hallelujah! This is great to hear from another Ortho that you do not need to fix everything, and being circumspect is super critical. Just gettting cut into has plenty of it’s own risks and side affects that are not always addressed up front by orthos. I have run the gambit due to a complicated ortho condition, knees(AVN), hips (AVN), shoulder, elbow, and, have made the hard choice to have several surgeries, ironically, not each labral tear (in hip or shoulder) was address. I did go to one “top” shoulder doctor that started talking to me saying that I needed Rotator cuff repair, along with a whole mess of other things…it just didn’t ring right. My MRI indicated a rotator cuff thickening not a full tear…I ultimately went with another shoulder specialist who treated the subacromial impingement and the massive buildup of scar tissue in that space that was creating a large source of pain. He looked at the rotator cuff and did some minor clean up but that was that. This resulted in a far more minimal surgery. I really appreciate when doctors say…you don’t need to fix that, tears in that position can be left alone. It is so much better to have a less is more approach than have the mindset that “when you have a hammer everything looks like a nail”. That is why I schelp nearly 2000 miles to orthos who think out of the box, treat you as a person, and fix what is needed, and generally don’t overfix.

  • Thanks¡
    At least im not feel alone in the same way of think. Sometimes i need rigen with collegues about the setter way of treatment, not only with thes conditions but other similar
    At the end we mus dont forget ,we are first at all doctors and we musa treat eche patient according his requeriments and not only his or her MR pathology
    Thanks again

  • I have had shoulder pain and markedly decreased range of motion for the past 5 months, to the point now that I cannot sleep or do my regular activities. I am an avid mountain and snow biker, golfer, and cross country skier, usually going 2-3 hours each day. I have tried therapy including daily stretching, strengthening, massage acupuncture, NSAIDs, heat and cold treatments. My physician does not recommend an MRI., probably because I am 64. What other options are there? This is really affecting my lifestyle.

    • Age is a not a good way to determine if you need an MRI. Age is a relative factor. IF therapy has not provided you with relief, then an MRI or Ultrasound would be useful to assess the integrity of the rotator cuff…. But please understand… many 60 somethings will have a degenerative rotator cuff tear and not even know it. The more important question is what you do with the MRI information. Will you have it repaired? What can be done to potentially reverse the degeneration? Check out the Rotation Medical Rotator Cuff Implant … something to discuss with your Orthopedist when you eventually see them.

      Good Luck

  • I have really good insurance ! Last weekend I had trouble sleeping because of shoulder pain then all of a sudden I couldn’t lift my arm . I woke my wife up and we went to urgent aid they diagnosed me with frozen shoulder . So after an MRI of my neck and shoulder I was told that I have a torn rotator cuff and three bulging disks but one week later I feel great my shoulder is getting stronger everyday . The bad part is I’m a 52 years old and a pipe fitter which means 90 % of my work is overhead and didn’t do this at work . Should I get surgery , And lose my job ? Or should I have the surgery and be out of work for several months with no money coming in ? Which would then mean putting tons of stress back on that shoulder .
    Very hard decision !

    • It is a VERY hard decision … the size of the tear matters … small tears can be watched… larger tears might benefit. Seek a few opinions if you need help making a decision.

  • I have full thickening of te supraspinatus años intraspinatus tendón. Also superior subluxation of húmedos edad, años severas condiciones on right shoulder. Two surgeries on it.

    I need your opinión of what yo do.

    • Once you have superior subluxation it is very unlikely that rotator cuff surgery will be successful.
      One of the ortho companies developed a procedure called a superior capsular reconstruction. In some patients with a large cuff tear AND superior migration this MIGHT be an appropriate procedure to consider. Talk it over with your doctor.

  • Dr. Luks,

    I’m a 55 yr old healthy male and former high school athlete. My MRI results show a full-thickness insertional supraspinatus tendon tear with less than 1 cm retraction and also a type II SLAP tear. The original acute injury likely occurred 30 years ago in college when I separated my shoulder in an intramural softball collision. I have five sons who have all played baseball, so I’ve done A LOT of overhead throwing and pitching batting practice my entire life. I aggravated my shoulder again last fall throwing way too much batting practice one day, and my shoulder pain will not go away as it had in the past when it got sore. I hope to continue doing a little throwing and also want to be able to play golf more as I get older. My shoulder pain is starting to wake me some at night and causing me to lose some sleep.

    Based on all of the above information, would you recommend surgery?

    • Not necessarily … certainly not on the SLAP lesion.. those almost never need surgery in adults.
      A degenerative rotator cuff tear is usually treated with therapy. Surgery is considered if PT doesn’t help minimize the pain and maximize function

      • My orthopedic surgeon insisted I do PT for 4-6 weeks. It helped a little. He then gave me a steroid injection. It didn’t help at all. That’s when he said an MRI would be a reasonable thing to do.The surgeon indicated the risk of not having it done is that it could eventually result in the need for a shoulder joint replacement. He said he could “trim” up the SLAP lesion while in repairing the rotator cuff tear.

  • I have a near full thickness tear of my subscapularus and a complex tear of my labrum. Can these issues be fixed at the same time during the same surgery?

    • Yes.. they can be. But, we often do not need to fix the labrum. The decision to fix the labrum depends on your age, injury, exam, etc.

  • Dr. Luks,

    I am a healthy 74 year old male. Surgery has been highly recommended for the following:

    Subacute full-thickness tear of the subscapularis tendon with partial retraction. Localized edema of the muscle belly and minimal fatty infiltration. Low-grade, probably chronic intrasubstance partial tears of the supraspinatus/infraspinatus at the footprint.

    I am experiencing a decrease in the ability to use my arm (right and I’m right-handed) and have trouble sleeping at night from the pain. During the day, I have very little pain and can do most routine daily things.

    Is the surgery recommendation a good idea? Thank for any input you may have.

    • The subscapularis is one of the two most important rotator cuff muscles. Most shoulder surgeons would manage a full tear surgically. But there are many variables that go into surgical decision making. The MRI result is only one variable. So I would consider a formal second opinion since I can not give you specific treatment recommendations.

  • I have a labrum tear in my shoulder I also have two bone spurs and bicep tendinitis. I’ve had four weeks of physical therapy and a Cortizone injection. It has helped some. My sleep at night is interrupted because of shoulder pain and my ability to lift something mid level and pour it is painful It is my primary arm of use. Right shoulder. My doctor is saying that I’m a good candidate for surgery to repair it. What is your thoughts? I’m nervous to get the surgery but I feel like I will not be able to continue to work and my sleep will continue to be interrupted unless I take pain pills or muscle relaxer. Thanks

    Sv

    • That type of pain is rarely due to a labral tear and often due to rotator cuff tendinosis. But without examining you I can not offer anything more.
      Good Luck

  • I am 55 years if age very active and have a torn labrum up near the bicep tendon. Would you recommend sugery.

    • Very very very few 50 somethings need surgery for a labral tear. The results of fixing a labral tear at our age are poor. So.. if surgery is entertained at some point then we usually recommend a “biceps tenodesis”. Hopefully you have a good shoulder doc who can explain your options to you. Most of us (Orthopedic surgeons) would initially recommend PT.

  • Hi, I had a surgeon look at me and my Mri. I sublexed a month ago in the turbulent river.. river sup surfing. I do this sport avidly and compete in a pro division. lots of water sports, water skiing, swimming.. diagnosis of MRI and surgeons ultrasound is: supraspinatus tendon is thinning w full thickness tear laterally , probable avulsion of anterior labrum. am doing PT. surgeon says it is probable I will dislocate in the future w my sports.. and that if I don’t get it fixed within a couple months the tissue can become irrepairable.. as tissue can turn to fat.. I heard this else where too.. I would like to try to repair myself.. and try my sup surf sport and water skiing when It is ” safe” ( originally prior to MRI I was given the 6 week mark on this) But now I am confused. I am going to send my MRI to another ortho and hope to be seen. In the mean time, trying to figure out the dos and do nots.. and the best course of action… if i loose a window where the shoulder can be fixed.. will i have to live w a shoulder that doesn’t work properly in the future? If I get it fixed, I have to go thru all that.. and will it work properly?

    • After a traumatic dislocation many/most people sustain a tear of the labrum on the front of the shoulder. For first time dislocators most sports docs would not recommend surgery. The issue is the potential for recurrence– meaning that the shoulder might dislocate again. The risk of having a second dislocation depends on someone’s age. The younger (under 25) the higher the risk Most sports docs would recommend surgery after your second dislocation. The labrum will be repairable for many years. It doesn’t become harder to repair, except if you start to have many many dislocations which starts to wear away the bone itself.

  • Hi Dr. Lukes,

    I dislocated my shoulder in a fall a few weeks ago. My ortho ordered an MRI and it showed a SLAP lesion from 10 o’clock posterior through the superior and into the anterior labrum. My work requires me to lift my arm over my head to flip switches and push buttons. He recommended surgery to repair the lesion, but this would mean I’ll be off work for 6 months. This is my first dislocation and I’m 31 years old. Is trying physical therapy before surgery a good option for me? Also, I’m moderately active (running and lifting).

    • Most first time dislocators are not operated on…. Perhaps in an elite athlete, or in people who can not risk a second dislocation (tree climbers, roofers, rock climbers, etc) Most other people wait for second dislocation before considering surgery…. since the risk of a second dislocation becomes lower with age.

  • Dear Dr Luke’s,
    I am so grateful to have found this page. On 12-8-17 I fell and dislocated my shoulder, the MRI stated that there is a -full thickness tears of distal supraspinous and infraspinatous tendons with approx 9mm of retraction. Tear measures 2.5 cm in AP dimension. Joint fluid extends through this defect into subacromial/subdeltoid space. A small joint effusion. I do not want surgery, is rehab a possibility for me? I’m 60 years young.

    Thanks so much,
    BC

    • Hi Bev…
      The treatment of rotator cuff tears is often dependent on the 1. The cause of the tears and 2. The size of the tears.
      Tears that occur after trauma– such as a dislocation are often treated surgically. They tend to heal well and result in a well functioning stable shoulder.
      Tears that are chronic and or degenerative– meaning no trauma or injury are usually observed or treated with physical therapy.

      Your tear is fairly large… two of the four muscles are involved. Your cause is acute trauma. Most all shoulder surgeons would agree that considering surgery might be your best option…. But only you and your doctor can make that decision. Please understand that I post for educational purposes and can not offer treatment advice as a physician in this forum.

      Good Luck !

      • Dear Dr. Luks,

        I appreciate you taking the time to help me understand my options, thank you. I don’t want to have the surgery that the doc recommended to me but I guess I’ll have to. I’ll be going for another opinion to another orthopedic Dr, because the initial Dr was just too eager to operate and wasn’t ordering a work up on my heart or any other precautions. I so appreciate your thoughts.

        😉
        Bev

Sorry, comments are closed.